- I found this experiment difficult. I found myself trying to say verbally what I wanted to say and I kept stopping. I could not get a pen and paper to explain to my partner what I was trying to tell them either. I felt so limited to my communication skills. It was just hard for me. My partner kept looking at me trying to figure out what I was trying to say and that made it harder for me because the confusion on her face. She kept asking "what", "I don't understand what you're trying to say", and "huh". She would repeat after me and I kept trying to tell her no and then explain what I was trying to say. If me and my partner were communicating for the first time from different cultures, I think she would have the upper hand just because she was able to talk and use her hands and write. Me on the other hand, I would be stuck and confused. I feel like the advantaged culture might have a curious attitude, like what is this creature trying to tell me, why can't they talk like me. Individuals in our culture that have difficulty speaking are the deaf. There is ways they can interact, like hand signals and lip-reading. I think it would only affect them if it just happened to them and they have to learn how to interact with people who can speak. If there was a baby born with it, then it is the parents jobs to teach them how to socially interact so they don't feel left out. I think it can have affects on the people who can interact by speaking just because it might frustrate them, they are trying to interact with someone who cannot interact like them. Others can be a lot more understanding and try to interact with them with hand signals or pen and paper.
- This part of the experiment was extremely hard for me, in a funny way though. I use my hands a lot when I talk. It is sort of a habit, even when I am trying to say something simple, I use my hands. I was not able to last the full fifteen minutes. I honestly lasted less than five minutes. Trying to tell my partner a story that happened at the movies with me and my boyfriend was really hard, I caught myself doing facial expressions like surprised for one. So I would stop and laugh, I was kind of getting mad because I really wanted to test myself to see if I really can't speak with hand signals or facial expressions. Those are like my main communication skill when I tell a story. My partner was my best friend and she knows me so well, she even uses hand signals and facial expressions, so she kept looking at me like "why are not showing any emotions". She asked me at the end "and you weren't scared" I had told her yeah but I can't show it because of the experiment so she tried telling me something without doing facial expressions and she agreed with me, it was hard.This experiment really showed me that I cannot talk effectively without hand signals or facial expressions. I think these skills that are part of communication can effect a conversation. The other person might not have a full understanding of what you are trying to tell them so it makes it harder. Understanding someone in a conversation is a part of good communication skills and these skills are necessary for the long run in life such as your career or school. The people I think that can have extreme difficulty reading body language is the blind. They cannot see so they won't be able to see your hand gestures or facial expressions or reactions when they hear something, unless they make a noise. The ability to read body language is greatly beneficial. We have the ability to see people's reactions and through these reactions we can see their emotions towards the subject. If someone is not able to speak, we can see it in their body language what they are trying to say, for example, if someone were to have a stroke, we can see in their face that they are hurt or incapable of verbally letting us know they are in pain and cannot move. The only place I can think of that body language might not be benficial is school or a classroom. We tend to judge people based on how they look so what if we walk in and see someone who seems like an outsider, does not talk to anybody, keeps to themselves, and does not speak when called upon. When they sit in class, they sit quietly, and they look kind of mad or in their own little world. They give off the vibe where no one wants to approach them or even try to engage in a converstion with them. Them giving us that body language, throws us off.
Tuesday, July 29, 2014
Language
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi Jessika,
ReplyDeleteIt seems like everyone had the same problem in the second part of the experiment: trying not to laugh. For some reason, it makes us feel so strange and ridiculous that the only thing we can think to do is laugh it off.
It was interesting how you said that you had to explain in words that you had been scared at the movies, since your friend could not tell from your body language. I think that in a way, by using both verbal language and physical expression, we are speaking two languages at once. If you had been able to act as if you had been scared, and changed your voice to sound nervous and agitated, your friend would have understood that you had been scared already. You would not have had to spend more time and energy telling her in words that you had been scared.
I think in several ways, nonverbal communication can be more effective than verbal, at least when communicating simple ideas. Seeing someone physically express and emotion or sensation generally causes more of a gut reaction in a person, rather than describing the emotion in words. Even while you were able to tell your partner in words that you had felt scared, I think your feeling would have seemed more sincere if you had communicated it through body language.
Good description on the first experiment and great discussion on the cultural issues. There might be a "curious" aspect, but often it can get less civilized, can't it? Another group in this situation are those from other cultures just learning the language. This inability to communicate is also at the core of why some people respond negatively to immigrants to this country, perhaps?
ReplyDeleteInteresting that your friend didn't believe that you were scared, even though you told her. Without the body language that supported to words, she wasn't sure if she should believe you or not. Humans tend to use body language as a lie detector for spoken language. If the words and the body language don't match up, we tend to not trust the information.
Yes, the blind have difficulty with body language, though they understand vocal intonation and can sense body position. Another group are those in the autism spectrum, characterized by the inability to read body language.
Okay on the suggestion of when it might be best to not read body language, though if we are thinking from a survival perspective, this may not be too crucial. Is there ever a situation where body language might lie to you? Do all cultures use the same body language?
in reference to your first paragraph where you said ". I feel like the advantaged culture might have a curious attitude, like what is this creature trying to tell me, why can't they talk like me." i found it interesting that you responded that way. i felt slightly different in saying that the advantaged culture may have a negative attitude. i felt this way with my example coming from the deaf community. those that are deaf are viewed by the hearing world as less capable/skilled/ intelligent due to their disability. but i do agree that there may be some curiosity in wanting to be able to communicate. awesome blog post i enjoyed reading.
ReplyDeleteHey Jessika
ReplyDeleteI'm agreeing with your points in this post! It's interesting (as Ashlee said above me) that you said the advantaged culture might have a curious attitude. I felt they would think of themselves as more superior in intelligence and, in that superiority, try to make the "lesser" culture more educated.
I like your statement of "Understanding someone in a conversation is a part of good communication skills and these skills are necessary for the long run in life such as your career or school." Body language is indeed useful and capable of helping everyone worldwide! Your example of the classroom was good as well. Society tends to judge people by appearance and that image of a reserved student would clearly leave us with the impression that this guy or girl does not want to be disturbed (which could be the complete opposite of what (s)he really wants). The downfall of body language could be from our fault as being too judgmental!